• Storytelling & Memory Keeping
    • Digital Scrapbooking Hybrid Scrapbooking Mobile Memory Keeping All
      December Daily

      What is December Daily?

      September 12, 2021

      Digital Scrapbooking

      Digital Scrapbooking Freebies are out there – Persnickety…

      July 18, 2018

      Digital Scrapbooking

      Project Life Digital – Freebies Are Out There…

      October 21, 2012

      Digital Scrapbooking

      Digital Project Life – How to get started?

      October 14, 2012

      Hybrid Scrapbooking

      Favourite Scrapbooking Tools – Silhouette Cameo 4

      September 13, 2021

      Hybrid Scrapbooking

      What is December Daily?

      September 12, 2021

      Mobile Memory Keeping

      Project Life App

      August 2, 2015

      Mobile Memory Keeping

      How to do Project 365 and how do…

      January 3, 2012

      Storytelling & Memory Keeping

      Favourite Scrapbooking Tools – Silhouette Cameo 4

      September 13, 2021

      Storytelling & Memory Keeping

      What is December Daily?

      September 12, 2021

      Storytelling & Memory Keeping

      Digital Scrapbooking Freebies are out there – Persnickety…

      July 18, 2018

      Storytelling & Memory Keeping

      2017 Project 365 – Preparations and Lessons Learnt

      December 31, 2016

  • Projects
    • December Daily Photography Project Life and Project 365 Wordless Wednesday All
      December Daily

      Favourite Scrapbooking Tools – Silhouette Cameo 4

      September 13, 2021

      December Daily

      What is December Daily?

      September 12, 2021

      December Daily

      Merry Christmas Everyone!!

      December 20, 2011

      Photography

      Digital Project Life – How to get started?

      October 14, 2012

      Photography

      Wordless Wednesday – Thomas & The Train Shed

      December 21, 2011

      Photography

      Wordless Wednesday ….

      November 16, 2011

      Photography

      Wordless Wednesday

      August 24, 2011

      Project Life and Project 365

      Favourite Scrapbooking Tools – Silhouette Cameo 4

      September 13, 2021

      Project Life and Project 365

      Digital Project Life – How to get started?

      October 14, 2012

      Project Life and Project 365

      How to do Project 365 and how do…

      January 3, 2012

      Wordless Wednesday

      Wordless Wednesday – Thomas & The Train Shed

      December 21, 2011

      Wordless Wednesday

      Wordless Wednesday ….

      November 16, 2011

      Wordless Wednesday

      Wordless ….

      October 9, 2011

      Wordless Wednesday

      Wordless Wednesday – Miss Outside

      September 21, 2011

      Craft Projects

      Favourite Scrapbooking Tools – Silhouette Cameo 4

      September 13, 2021

      Craft Projects

      What is December Daily?

      September 12, 2021

      Craft Projects

      Digital Project Life – How to get started?

      October 14, 2012

      Craft Projects

      How to do Project 365 and how do…

      January 3, 2012

  • Life
    • Community & Kids Disability Grateful Inspiration Laughter, Song & Dance Mind & Spirit Play & Rest Technology Travel All
      Community & Kids

      Carers Allowance & 2018 Federal Budget

      July 19, 2018

      Community & Kids

      Pool Safety … Is Your Pool Ready For…

      October 19, 2012

      Community & Kids

      Autism and Travel Insurance

      October 4, 2012

      Community & Kids

      School Holiday Ideas – Thomas & the Train…

      September 24, 2012

      Disability

      Carers Allowance & 2018 Federal Budget

      July 19, 2018

      Disability

      Social Model Of Disability And Why It Is…

      July 8, 2018

      Disability

      iOS Guided Access – How to help focus…

      June 8, 2013

      Disability

      Autism and Travel Insurance

      October 4, 2012

      Grateful

      Grateful for TED

      September 24, 2011

      Grateful

      Grateful for … Spoken Word

      September 15, 2011

      Grateful

      Grateful for … Poetry

      September 8, 2011

      Grateful

      Grateful for … our GP

      August 23, 2011

      Inspiration

      Some Days I Miss … the Theatre

      December 29, 2011

      Inspiration

      Favourite Quotations – Steve Jobs – Change the…

      November 21, 2011

      Inspiration

      Grateful for TED

      September 24, 2011

      Inspiration

      Grateful for … Spoken Word

      September 15, 2011

      Laughter, Song & Dance

      Most Wuthering Heights Day Ever 2018 – An…

      July 15, 2018

      Laughter, Song & Dance

      If Moms Talked to Each Other The Way…

      October 17, 2015

      Laughter, Song & Dance

      Friday Funny: Lullaby

      August 24, 2012

      Laughter, Song & Dance

      Friday Funny – Fotoshop by Adobé

      April 20, 2012

      Mind & Spirit

      I Miss My Dad

      April 29, 2012

      Mind & Spirit

      Grateful for TED

      September 24, 2011

      Mind & Spirit

      Less than perfect – Good Enough Mum

      August 16, 2011

      Mind & Spirit

      Words of Wisdom for New Mums

      January 19, 2009

      Play & Rest

      If Moms Talked to Each Other The Way…

      October 17, 2015

      Play & Rest

      Review: Sydney Good Food and Wine Show

      June 24, 2012

      Play & Rest

      Get Your Motors Running – Autism Motorcyle Ride

      April 20, 2012

      Play & Rest

      Royal Easter Show 2012 – Last minute Show…

      April 6, 2012

      Technology

      iOS Guided Access – How to help focus…

      June 8, 2013

      Technology

      Do you Backup Your Blog?

      September 22, 2012

      Technology

      Apple Junkie: Preview of iOS5

      June 6, 2011

      Travel

      Things I love about London – St Pauls

      March 9, 2012

      Travel

      Things I love about London – British Museum

      February 29, 2012

      Travel

      Things I Love About London – Tower of…

      February 9, 2012

      Travel

      Crazy Dreams – Vespa Ape

      July 24, 2011

      Stories of Life

      Remembering 9/11 20 Years On

      September 11, 2021

      Stories of Life

      Carers Allowance & 2018 Federal Budget

      July 19, 2018

      Stories of Life

      Most Wuthering Heights Day Ever 2018 – An…

      July 15, 2018

      Stories of Life

      Social Model Of Disability And Why It Is…

      July 8, 2018

  • Stories
  • Instagram
  • About me
    • Contact Me
    • Guest Post Submission Guidelines
N My Life
- crafting life -
Tag:

courts

Community & Kids

Consequences of their actions

by bronwyn April 19, 2012
written by bronwyn

Today I was reading an interesting article over at MamaMia about Pedophiles and Privacy … Do Pedophiles have a right to Privacy? I think it is a wel written article and raises some interesting questions for the community to discuss and something that needs to be revisited.

So what’s the issue? Current legislation allows for offenders of serious crime to apply to the courts to have their names and details suppressed. And while  high profile criminal cases occasionally have details suppressed, it happens most often with pedophiles and serious sex offenders. The question that in my mind that comes up is why do pedophiles and sex offenders require ‘special’ treatment? Murderers, arsonists, thieves, extortionists, embezzlers  all have their names in the public domain … plastered across newspaper (on and off-line), radio, tv, blogs and Facebook. So should pedophiles and sex offenders require be exempt? What are the issues at play?

First … what exactly are Suppression Orders? How do they work?

Suppression and Non-publications orders are a extremely important and powerful tools used by the courts to protect the identify of people. Some of the reasons for issuing suppression orders include

  • to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice,
  • to prevent prejudice to the interests … in relation to national or international security,
  • to protect the safety of any person,
  • to avoid causing undue distress or embarrassment to a party to or witness in criminal proceedings involving an offence of a sexual nature (including an act of indecency).

There are three main types of protection under the umbrella of suppression orders:

  • to close the courtroom to the public;
  • to prohibit any publication of the details of the matter; and/or
  • to provide for the use of pseudonyms for all parties and the exclusion of any other identifying information, so that when the decision is published or reported in the media, the people cannot be identified.

What does this mean in practice?

Suppression orders are a balancing act. The competing interests of open and transparent justice (a integral part of our justice system is that both justice be done but also seen to be done – read a brillant article on that here) and of the individual’s right to privacy, fair trial and the resumption of a relatively normal life after serving one’s debt to society.

There are many reasons why suppression orders are requested by lawyers but among the most common is to ensure that their client gets a fair trial.  In other words, that his or her name is not subjected to biased, malicious, and ill-informed reporting by the media, which will make it harder for an individual to be judged purely on the evidence before the court, and not on emotive and prejudicial images and stories that have been published in the lead-up to the trial. You don’t necessarily need to look hard to learn why sometimes they are issued. A good example is Brendan Sokaluk who was arrested shortly after the February 2009 Victorian bushfires.  Vigilante groups set up Facebook pages, his family was harassed and subject to media stories and the Herald Sun was forced to remove readers’ comments from its stories on him. That newspaper also ran stories about Sokaluk, which portrayed him as a “loner who went to a special school, he tried to become a CFA volunteer for years but was always knocked back.”

So … I think that it is easy to see that when suppression orders are created to preserve the integrity of the judicial process (ie to ensure that a person gets a fair trial where they are presumed innocent), to protect victims and witnesses (both before, during and after trial) and for national security reasons they can do a great service to the community …  but when I think greater scrutiny is required is after the conclusion of a trial (or extended judicial proceedings). And I think this is at the heart of the MamaMia Article … what rights to privacy do convicted criminals have? Should pedophiles and sex-offenders have special protections because of the prejudices and fear within the community against them? Should the privacy and right for a convicted pedophiles and sex-offenders to resume of a relatively normal life after serving one’s debt to society outweigh the rights of the community?

My first thoughts

I  believe that open justice is central to the premise of democracy. It is central to our rules and norms of our society that not only that justice be done … that it be seen to be done. Crimes must be acknowledged and where it does not adversely affect victims of crime, criminals should be held account for their actions. I am not saying that they should be branded or made to hold up signs or be held in shackles on Martin Place … but it should be available as part of the public record. The case of the pedophile Peter Versi is a perfect example. The victim gave permission so why wasn’t he named originally? Because his barrister successfully argued that to not suppress his name would be ”catastrophic” to his reputation and business activity. His barrister, Anthony Bellanto, QC, asked the District Court judge Ken Taylor to grant a non-publication order on his client’s name because the offender planned to resume his career, either after release from prison or a successful appeal. ”We wish to minimise any ongoing damage to his reputation,” Mr Bellanto said. ”It would help if he could reduce the … damage that will no doubt occur if these matters reach the electronic and print media.”  The Crown prosecutor, Sarah Huggett, said under the principles of open justice, the offender had no right to have his name suppressed. IMHO …why shouldn’t his professional reputation be damaged because of his actions?

My first thoughts as a parent is that I want to protect my family and I therefore want to know if there are any convicted sex offenders or pedophiles living or working near me. I am a total NIMBY on this issue … like I think everyone is. For me the current research suggests that the risks of recidivism (sex offenders and pedophiles re-offending and committing similar acts) is just to great and I don’t want them anywhere near me or my family. And I don’t think I am alone on this one. You only have to think about what happened to Dennis Ferguson. Being  hounded across the country by mobs of angry locals each time his whereabouts became known. I know he has to live somewhere … but I wouldn’t want it to be anywhere near my family. I know I wouldn’t want to live or work with one. I just don’t trust the system and I believe that the rights of the community to be protected outweigh the rights of pedophiles and sex-offenders to remain anonymous.

I also admire the conviction of people like Derryn Hinch who work with victims to inform and protect the community about pedophiles and sex-offenders. And while I do not always agree with his actions (and hey with the advantage of hindsight I don’t always agree with my own … so why should I hold anyone else to a higher standard) I admire his conviction and desire to both inform the community and keep discussion alive about the risks and dangers .. for example today I have learnt from his website that Cardinal Pell once said “Abortion is a worse moral scandal  than priests sexually abusing young people.” (something I confirmed from the SMH) and that there are people within the church who have committed criminal acts against children whom the Church had counselled, removed from the Ministry but kept in other jobs and protected from any Police investigation. Simply put … that is just wrong.

Opposing thoughts …

According to  Nigel Waters, head of the Privacy Branch in the Office of the Privacy Commissioner in his paper – PAEDOPHILIA: POLICY AND PREVENTION – Implications for Civil Liberties and Implications of Privacy Laws

Should convicted and suspected sex offenders have any civil liberties and rights to privacy? The answer, in a civilised society, must surely be yes. The rights of those offenders who have served court imposed sentences, while they are certainly diminished, are not extinguished completely. Many within the community would disagree. They argue unequivocally that in committing their offences, these types of offenders have infringed on the freedoms and rights of their victims and in so doing, have forfeited any rights enjoyed by other members of the community.

This view sits uncomfortably with concepts which are fundamental to our system of justice and our commitment to human rights. We have democratically established institutions which attempt to achieve the delicate balance between crime and punishment, restitution and rehabilitation. In a number of ways, unofficial registers such as The Australian Paedophile and Sex Offender Index fundamentally challenge these notions. So, to a lesser extent, would some of the more draconian proposals for official registers and vetting systems.

The Australian Paedophile and Sex Offender Index, in particular, undermines the principle of rehabilitation which is an important objective of our justice system. We have established a system where a judgement about an appropriate sentence is made after deliberation by an experienced public official and often after consideration of evidence by a fully informed jury made up of members of the community. Once any sentence imposed has been completed, our justice system says that a person should have the opportunity to reintegrate back into the community. Information about the offence is still on the public record and is available to be taken into account in sentencing decisions should the person reoffend. This information is also available through official systems where criminal history checks are conducted in circumstances where such information is deemed relevant, for example, where persons are being employed in positions of trust with children.

The availability of information about convicted offenders more widely within the community can operate to extend the punishment already received by the offender. The result being that a person who has served his/her sentence is doubly punished and can be subjected potentially to a lifetime of persecution, victimisation and possible violence.

Public release of the identities and whereabouts of convicted offenders also places their families at risk of being stigmatised and persecuted and effectively punished for a crime purely by association. In some cases, this prospect may also deter victims from coming forward if the perpetrator is within the family.

To be honest like most people I hadn’t really thought too much about the civil liberties and rights to privacy of  convicted pedophiles and sex-offenders in the past … with the exemption of not wanting them around me or my family. But if the community is open to allowing their names to be published and open in the community … what should happen to convicted pedophiles and sex-offenders after they are released? With their names out in the open who would employ them? Like me who would want them part of their neighbourhoods or communities? How should they be re-integrated into the community? Recently I had watch a fictional program Secret Lives (watch on Youtube 1 – 2 – 3 – 4– 5) that covered these issue. After watching that … I know I don’t have the answers … It doesn’t change what I believe about the openness of justice and or the rights of the community to be protected … but I don’t have answers to these questions? What do you think?

Image: Stop Sign With Man’s Hand by Nutdanai Apikhomboonwaroot – FreeDigitalPhotos.net

April 19, 2012 0 comment
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail

About Me

About Me

Hi, I'm Bronwyn. I like to eat, laugh, take photos, tell stories, dream, help people & balance that with being a mum of 2 autistic kids. All my own opinions

Keep in touch

Facebook Twitter Instagram Pinterest Goodreads

Recent Posts

  • Favourite Scrapbooking Tools – Silhouette Cameo 4

    September 13, 2021
  • What is December Daily?

    September 12, 2021
  • Remembering 9/11 20 Years On

    September 11, 2021
  • Carers Allowance & 2018 Federal Budget

    July 19, 2018

Instagram

Categories

  • Craft Projects (10)
    • December Daily (3)
    • Photography (4)
    • Project Life and Project 365 (3)
    • Wordless Wednesday (5)
  • Retire (3)
  • Stories of Life (175)
    • Community & Kids (59)
    • Disability (51)
    • Grateful (7)
    • Inspiration (11)
    • Laughter, Song & Dance (18)
    • Mind & Spirit (4)
    • Play & Rest (14)
    • Technology (3)
    • Travel (9)
  • Storytelling & Memory Keeping (14)
    • Digital Scrapbooking (9)
    • Hybrid Scrapbooking (2)
    • Mobile Memory Keeping (2)

Recent Posts

  • Favourite Scrapbooking Tools – Silhouette Cameo 4

    September 13, 2021
  • What is December Daily?

    September 12, 2021
  • Remembering 9/11 20 Years On

    September 11, 2021

Categories

  • Storytelling & Memory Keeping
  • Craft Projects
  • Stories of Life
    • Disability
    • Grateful
    • Laughter, Song & Dance
    • Play & Rest
    • Travel

Popular Posts

  • 1

    Digital Scrapbooking Freebies are out there – Persnickety Prints

    July 18, 2018
  • 2

    How to do Project 365 and how do I do it with Instagram?

    January 3, 2012
  • 3

    Project Life Digital – Freebies Are Out There ..

    October 21, 2012

Instagram

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Goodreads

@2021 - Bronwyn Orsatti

N My Life
  • Storytelling & Memory Keeping
    • Digital Scrapbooking Hybrid Scrapbooking Mobile Memory Keeping All
      December Daily

      What is December Daily?

      September 12, 2021

      Digital Scrapbooking

      Digital Scrapbooking Freebies are out there – Persnickety…

      July 18, 2018

      Digital Scrapbooking

      Project Life Digital – Freebies Are Out There…

      October 21, 2012

      Digital Scrapbooking

      Digital Project Life – How to get started?

      October 14, 2012

      Hybrid Scrapbooking

      Favourite Scrapbooking Tools – Silhouette Cameo 4

      September 13, 2021

      Hybrid Scrapbooking

      What is December Daily?

      September 12, 2021

      Mobile Memory Keeping

      Project Life App

      August 2, 2015

      Mobile Memory Keeping

      How to do Project 365 and how do…

      January 3, 2012

      Storytelling & Memory Keeping

      Favourite Scrapbooking Tools – Silhouette Cameo 4

      September 13, 2021

      Storytelling & Memory Keeping

      What is December Daily?

      September 12, 2021

      Storytelling & Memory Keeping

      Digital Scrapbooking Freebies are out there – Persnickety…

      July 18, 2018

      Storytelling & Memory Keeping

      2017 Project 365 – Preparations and Lessons Learnt

      December 31, 2016

  • Projects
    • December Daily Photography Project Life and Project 365 Wordless Wednesday All
      December Daily

      Favourite Scrapbooking Tools – Silhouette Cameo 4

      September 13, 2021

      December Daily

      What is December Daily?

      September 12, 2021

      December Daily

      Merry Christmas Everyone!!

      December 20, 2011

      Photography

      Digital Project Life – How to get started?

      October 14, 2012

      Photography

      Wordless Wednesday – Thomas & The Train Shed

      December 21, 2011

      Photography

      Wordless Wednesday ….

      November 16, 2011

      Photography

      Wordless Wednesday

      August 24, 2011

      Project Life and Project 365

      Favourite Scrapbooking Tools – Silhouette Cameo 4

      September 13, 2021

      Project Life and Project 365

      Digital Project Life – How to get started?

      October 14, 2012

      Project Life and Project 365

      How to do Project 365 and how do…

      January 3, 2012

      Wordless Wednesday

      Wordless Wednesday – Thomas & The Train Shed

      December 21, 2011

      Wordless Wednesday

      Wordless Wednesday ….

      November 16, 2011

      Wordless Wednesday

      Wordless ….

      October 9, 2011

      Wordless Wednesday

      Wordless Wednesday – Miss Outside

      September 21, 2011

      Craft Projects

      Favourite Scrapbooking Tools – Silhouette Cameo 4

      September 13, 2021

      Craft Projects

      What is December Daily?

      September 12, 2021

      Craft Projects

      Digital Project Life – How to get started?

      October 14, 2012

      Craft Projects

      How to do Project 365 and how do…

      January 3, 2012

  • Life
    • Community & Kids Disability Grateful Inspiration Laughter, Song & Dance Mind & Spirit Play & Rest Technology Travel All
      Community & Kids

      Carers Allowance & 2018 Federal Budget

      July 19, 2018

      Community & Kids

      Pool Safety … Is Your Pool Ready For…

      October 19, 2012

      Community & Kids

      Autism and Travel Insurance

      October 4, 2012

      Community & Kids

      School Holiday Ideas – Thomas & the Train…

      September 24, 2012

      Disability

      Carers Allowance & 2018 Federal Budget

      July 19, 2018

      Disability

      Social Model Of Disability And Why It Is…

      July 8, 2018

      Disability

      iOS Guided Access – How to help focus…

      June 8, 2013

      Disability

      Autism and Travel Insurance

      October 4, 2012

      Grateful

      Grateful for TED

      September 24, 2011

      Grateful

      Grateful for … Spoken Word

      September 15, 2011

      Grateful

      Grateful for … Poetry

      September 8, 2011

      Grateful

      Grateful for … our GP

      August 23, 2011

      Inspiration

      Some Days I Miss … the Theatre

      December 29, 2011

      Inspiration

      Favourite Quotations – Steve Jobs – Change the…

      November 21, 2011

      Inspiration

      Grateful for TED

      September 24, 2011

      Inspiration

      Grateful for … Spoken Word

      September 15, 2011

      Laughter, Song & Dance

      Most Wuthering Heights Day Ever 2018 – An…

      July 15, 2018

      Laughter, Song & Dance

      If Moms Talked to Each Other The Way…

      October 17, 2015

      Laughter, Song & Dance

      Friday Funny: Lullaby

      August 24, 2012

      Laughter, Song & Dance

      Friday Funny – Fotoshop by Adobé

      April 20, 2012

      Mind & Spirit

      I Miss My Dad

      April 29, 2012

      Mind & Spirit

      Grateful for TED

      September 24, 2011

      Mind & Spirit

      Less than perfect – Good Enough Mum

      August 16, 2011

      Mind & Spirit

      Words of Wisdom for New Mums

      January 19, 2009

      Play & Rest

      If Moms Talked to Each Other The Way…

      October 17, 2015

      Play & Rest

      Review: Sydney Good Food and Wine Show

      June 24, 2012

      Play & Rest

      Get Your Motors Running – Autism Motorcyle Ride

      April 20, 2012

      Play & Rest

      Royal Easter Show 2012 – Last minute Show…

      April 6, 2012

      Technology

      iOS Guided Access – How to help focus…

      June 8, 2013

      Technology

      Do you Backup Your Blog?

      September 22, 2012

      Technology

      Apple Junkie: Preview of iOS5

      June 6, 2011

      Travel

      Things I love about London – St Pauls

      March 9, 2012

      Travel

      Things I love about London – British Museum

      February 29, 2012

      Travel

      Things I Love About London – Tower of…

      February 9, 2012

      Travel

      Crazy Dreams – Vespa Ape

      July 24, 2011

      Stories of Life

      Remembering 9/11 20 Years On

      September 11, 2021

      Stories of Life

      Carers Allowance & 2018 Federal Budget

      July 19, 2018

      Stories of Life

      Most Wuthering Heights Day Ever 2018 – An…

      July 15, 2018

      Stories of Life

      Social Model Of Disability And Why It Is…

      July 8, 2018

  • Stories
  • Instagram
  • About me
    • Contact Me
    • Guest Post Submission Guidelines